A strong manuscript is only part of the equation – successful submissions require strategy. Knowing who to approach, how to position your book, how to choose your opening scene and how to tailor your materials can make the difference between a pass and a request.

‘Is my book ready for submission?’ This is one of the hardest judgement calls for a writer to make. Any writer can edit, edit and edit some more, but putting down the pen and underlining ‘The End’ can often feel impossible.

This guide is designed to help you navigate the essentials to decide if your book is ready to take off towards the overcrowded inboxes of literary agents and publishers. We will identify key signs that your book is ready (or not quite yet), recommend a practical manuscript checklist and offer some submission tips to boost your confidence and polish your pitch.

Have I edited enough?

Before you even think about submitting, your manuscript should not just be finished, but must be refined. If you’ve just penned your first draft, chances are your book is not ready. Most manuscripts go through multiple drafts and revisions before they become submission-ready.

Not sure where to start with revising your manuscript? It’s best to consider the keystones of successful fiction: structure, narrative, character and style.

Structurally

Is your narrative arc complete? How is your pacing: rushed, laborious, sagging in the middle act? Are there any gaping plot holes that need stitching closed? Is your structure working hard for your themes and characters?

Narratively

Is voice distinctive? Is perspective effective and consistent? Have you nailed down your tenses and made certain any perspective or tense shifts are controlled and clear? Have you balanced action, reflection and description to create depth?

Stylistically

Have you balanced ‘showing not telling’ to avoid explanatory prose? Is your prose underwritten, overwritten or just right? Does your style choice fit the genre you are writing? Does it enhance or undermine perspective and voice? On a practical note, have you varied your rhythm and syntax purposefully to create a dynamic and textured text that works to boost atmosphere?

Character-wise

Do your main characters have complete character arcs? Are their motivations clear and credible throughout? Have you built depth into their relationships? Are their actions and reactions serving to progress your narrative? Is their dialogue well-realised, avoiding cliché, stilted tone and hyper-realism?

Housekeeping

Have you proofread your manuscript? Is your formatting correct?

Have I sought outside feedback?

Even the most diligent self-editor can miss things. That’s why external feedback is crucial. A fresh pair of objective eyes, unblinkered by the rose-tinted spectacles of authorship, are invaluable.

There are a number of options available to writers who need some outside input: 

Beta readers: These are non-professional readers who can offer insight into how your story lands. Friends, family and reading groups are great options, but beware of bias from those you know well.

Critique partners: Fellow writers who exchange manuscripts and provide detailed feedback. These can often be found on creative message boards or online writing groups.

Did the story feel cohesive? Was the story clear? Were there any confusing sections? Did the characters evolve naturally and did you care about them? Did the prose flow and feel immersive? Did you want to keep reading? Were you left with unanswered questions?

While beta-readers can tell good from bad storytelling, it’s best not to ask non-editors for technical feedback on pace or . Instead, treat them as your test audience and ask them what you would ask any stranger who might buy your book.

Then of course, there are also professional editors. A manuscript assessor, developmental or copy editor can give you expert, industry-specific feedback and help you elevate your work with editorial polish and insider knowledge.

Act on the feedback you receive but remember that it is subjective. You might disagree and that is not a sign that you’re ungrateful or wrong. Some feedback will be more valuable and discerning, whilst some will be less useful and can be put aside with a polite ‘thank you’.

If you’ve received consistent positive feedback, made thoughtful revisions and seen improvements expressed by your test audience, that’s a strong sign your book is closer to submission.

Does my book fit the market?

Publishing and authorship might have a romantic reputation and an aura about it, but always remember that at its core, it is a business. Its focus,  and its reason for accepting or rejecting your work, will always come down to market appeal.

Agents and publishers aren’t just looking for good writing, with powerful voice and memorable characters, they’re looking for marketable writing. To be marketable, your book needs to be confidently settled in its genre. Operationally, Marketing and Publicity will want to know to which of their segments they need to aim with their campaigns for your book.

Identifying your genre and subgenre is essential. This should shape not only to whom and how you pitch your book, but how it is written. Your story should meet reader expectations for its category, or it will be difficult to pitch difficult to represent and difficult to market. If you’re not sure what your book is and where it would fit on a shelf, how will your literary agent?

Make an effort to understand your niche. It pays to be aware of at least three to five comparable titles published in the last five years, and how they performed after release. This shows agents that you have done your research and considered what your book offers the current market – emphasis on current.

Is my submission package ready?

Submitting a novel isn’t just about the manuscript, it’s about the pre-submission strategy.

Here’s what most agents expect:

Query Letter

Your pitch: hook, summary, and credentials. You should include an explanation of why you have chosen that specific agent. What makes them right for your book? Is there a gap that you can fill to complement their current lists? Give them a brief bio, they want to know who they might be working with. They don’t need your whole life story, just a few interesting details about the person behind the pen that would sound interesting in an interview, for example.

Synopsis

A one-page summary of your plot. This should give a full overview of your narrative, showing the agent how your plot works. It is necessary to reveal the cogs and levers to reassure the agent or publisher that your story is complete and well formed. Writers often fear they reveal too much in the synopsis, but the point is to reveal everything. When in doubt, say more.  

Sample pages

Usually the first 50 pages or first three chapters. This is your book’s chance to make a first impression that leaves an agent or publisher eager for more. With a punchy hook, good pace and editorial polish, it should show the best of your writing and a promise of more to come. A common difficulty is that the first chapters are not always the best chapters. The ending is better, some writers often tell us. If that’s the case, it helps to remember that the structure of your manuscript is not always the structure that makes it into the printed book. Don’t be afraid of using a prologue, for example, and show flexibility in your cover to the agent about the final position of that prologue scene. That’s what a strategic approach to submissions does, it decides trade-offs for both best impression and correct positioning.   

Always check with each submission what the agent in question is asking for. Some will want a query letter in an email with attached documents, some may not. Never assume there is a ‘standard’ approach and please don’t make the simple error of not reading the instructions. Practice your pitch. Try it out on friends, family or your local or online writing groups. How effective do they think it is? Would they be inclined to request more? Or are they left unmoved?

Final editing before submission

Before you hit ‘send’, run through this final manuscript checklist:

• Title page with contact info
•  Proper formatting (12pt font, double-spaced, Times New Roman)
•  Clean, simple and professional file name (e.g., LastName_Title.docx)
•  No track changes or comments left in the document post-edit
•  Query letter and synopsis saved and attached separately

It can be helpful to use a spreadsheet or notebook to keep track of which agents you have submitted to and when. This will help you manage timeframes and prevent duplicate submissions.

Is my manuscript  really ready?

If you’ve revised thoroughly, gathered feedback, polished your pages and prepared a proper submission package, then yes, your manuscript is ready to be submitted.

Remember: rejection is part of the journey. Every no brings you closer to the right yes. Pitching and publishing is a process that is not always linear.

If you’re finding that rejections are coming thick and fast, use that as information. It may well be that agents are looking elsewhere or have no editors in their network to sell the rights to. This is more common than you’d think.

It may also be that there something about your book or your pitch that isn’t hitting the mark with readers.

Performing some pitch triage with an objective reader or a professional editor could be the answer to spotting what’s missing.

You can always check out our Submission Package Review service to see how a professional editor can help you be strategic about the way you submit your manuscript to agents.

© Photo: urbazon/Getty Images